Is a Popping Knee a Sign of Torn Meniscus or Chiropractic Imbalance?

| September 16, 2017 | 3 Comments

4th of July FireworksWhat does it mean when your knee starts popping and swelling? Is it because of a tear in the meniscus or is it because of a maladjusted spine? At my age I’m used to the sandy sound of chondromalacia, but the popping and swelling is a whole new adventure.

When the Knee Popping Began

About 3 or 4 months ago I noticed my right knee started making a popping sound. It didn’t hurt, nor did it pop all the time. It would pop about 3 or 4 times a day so I just figured it was a part of aging. It didn’t stop me from anything I was doing so I pretty much ignored it.

Several months later (last week), the popping intensified to several times an hour and the knee started swelling. I sounded like I had my own portable 4th of July fireworks going on everytime I moved. The popping I could deal with, but the swelling was uncomfortable. It got to the point where I couldn’t straighten my leg. This stopped me from my normal activities so I knew it was time (actually past time) for me to do something about it.

Chiropractic Intervention

I believed the knee popping was a result of poorly aligned hips. My current chiropractor (who solved my sciatica problem) didn’t have one of those “drop” tables like my old chiropractor had. With the drop table my old chiropractor was able to work his magic and get my poorly aligned, up-twisted right hip and down-twisted left hip back in sync. Without the drop table, the hips just weren’t budging.

Out with the New and in with the Old

So, I called my old chiropractor who I hadn’t seen in over 5 years. The first question I asked was whether or not he still had the drop table. Of course he did so I made an appointment.

Just an aside: I’m not tossing out either of my chiropractors. I’m keeping them both. I now know their strengths and weaknesses. If my sciatica begins to clear her ugly throat, I’ll go to chiropractor #2. If my hips/knees get funky, I’ll call chiropractor #1. They both will remain in my health arsenal. After all, traditional medicine requires a general practitioner, ear nose throat specialist, cardiologist, oncologist, proctologist, gynecologist, etc., etc., etc. I’ll keep my 2 chiro guys.

After catching up on what we’ve been doing for the past 5 years, he evaluated me. And, just as I suspected, my hips were twisted. He put me on the table, and with a few hip drops things were temporarily aligned again. I say temporarily because it takes more than one visit to get adjustments to set.

Cold Laser Treatment on the KneeCold Laser

We both agreed the popping sound had something to do with the poor hip alignment, but he wasn’t so sure that was the entire problem. There was quite a bit of swelling so a proper evaluation of the knee had to wait until after some of the swelling went down. He did mention concern about my meniscus, but couldn’t be sure without an MRI. In the meanwhile after the adjustment he applied a cold laser treatment to the affected area.

Cold laser treatments are not painful at all. The laser looks sort of like a flashlight. He felt for the source of the swelling and aimed the laser there. We chatted for a few more minutes while the laser did its thing.

The affects of the first laser treatment lasts for about 5 hours or so after application. My knee was still swollen, but it felt a bit more stable after the adjustment and laser treatment. I’m very fortunate because throughout this process I did not experience knee pain.

Five Hours after the Laser Treatment

Around 4.5 to 5 hours after the treatment I started to notice my knee again. No pain, just the swelling and discomfort of swelling. And yes, it was still popping. Noticing my knee again and my chiropractor’s mention of possible tear in the meniscus sent me on an internet search.

I’ve vicariously lived through the experience of meniscus surgery. My husband had it 15 years ago and his knee still isn’t right. He has a scar going down the front of his leg and I want no parts of that. His injury was also very severe. He tore his ACL, meniscus and shattered part of his femur. OUCH! Mine is just a possible little tear.Human Knee

What is the Meniscus and What does it Do?

The first thing I did in my search was try to get a better understanding of what the meniscus is. I knew it had something to do with cushioning the knee joints but couldn’t quite wrap my head around how it worked.

I’m not going to attempt to get technical, but the meniscus is cartilage that cushions the bones that meet at the knee, the thigh and shin bones(femur and tibia). Each knee has two menisci. That’s about as technical as I can get. For more technical explanations check out these articles:

The knee is a very complicated joint with all kinds of ligaments, tendons, fluid and things to keep it functioning properly. From what I’ve learned and witnessed with my husband, a damaged meniscus could be a very painful condition. I feel fortunate that my situation only resulted in painless swelling and popping.

Because I feel my condition is not nearly as serious as some I’ve read about or witnessed, I’m opting for the natural healing route instead of surgery.

Healing the Knee Naturally

We do not know whether or not I actually have a torn meniscus. Without an MRI we won’t know for sure. in the meanwhile, in addition to chiropractic intervention I decided to do everything I could to help my knee feel better. To that end, I went online to find out everything I could about self-healing a potentially torn meniscus.

I found several informative and promising articles. Below are just a few. The one that particularly struck me was the first one listed below, written by a 67 year old woman (she was 67 at the time of the writing) who had torn her meniscus on two separate occasions. First she tore one knee then the other and opted to heal both naturally.Peppermint Essential Oil

Using Essential Oils for Knee Healing

As a result of the research I pulled out my essential oils and far infrared mineral lamp. Several articles talked about the benefits of essential oils for knee healing. I also learned that by layering the oils they retain their original therapeutic properties whereas combining in a carrier oil may synergistically alter the properties. Either way, no harm is being done. So I gathered the oils and began layering them on the affected area. I used 1-2 drops of each of the following oils (I use Rocky Mountain Essential Oils):

  • Clove
  • Ginger
  • Lemongrass
  • Sweet Marjoram
  • Peppermint

The layering process takes anywhere from 5 to 10 minutes because I waited a minute or two for each oil to absorb before applying the next one. After they were all applied I sat under the far infrared lamp for about 20 minutes. I did this 3 times a day. What I did notice was a reduction in swelling. The knee still popped, but not as frequently as before.

In addition to the oils and lamp, I decided to start drinking homemade bone broth again. The collagen in the broth is great for joints. To that I’ve added glucosamine/chondroitin and MSM and of course took vitamin C. If my knee is compromised and in need of repair, I want to give it as many building blocks as I can to help it heal.

In addition to the above, I continued to see my chiropractor three times a week. With each visit he applied the cold laser therapy to the epicenter of the discomfort.

Exercise Routine for Rehabbing Knee

Because the knee was still in the healing process and too much walking seemed to bother it, I gave up my usual daily walks for a few more days (I really missed those walks). Instead, as the swelling decreased I was able to hop on my bike and ride a couple miles each day. Not only did my chiropractor suggest biking, but I read that biking and swimming were good exercises for rehabbing a compromised meniscus.Biking for Knee Rehab

While biking I noticed something interesting. I noticed a an endurance difference in the leg that was treated with the oils. Because I don’t often bike ride, my thigh muscles were introduced to a different way of operating. The more I pedaled, the more I began to feel the burn in my left leg (the leg that did not receive the essential oil treatment). The right leg , on the other hand, was ready to continue riding.

At first I couldn’t understand why only one thigh muscle felt the burn until I realized it must be the essential oils. I’ve used a homemade preparation of peppermint, rosemary, ginger, eucalyptus in the past to treat sore muscles after a workout. I’ve never used them prior to a workout. This little accidental experiment is a game changer. Now I’ll apply the oils prior to working out for endurance. I read somewhere that essential oils are like legal doping. Too bad more athletes aren’t aware of this.

And the Treatment Continues

I’m a week and a half into my knee improvement protocol. The first visit to my chiropractor was Tuesday, September 5th. I felt a little improvement after visit #1. After visit #2 two days later,I felt like a new woman. I was able to begin biking over the weekend, just 4 days after my first visit.

As I write this, I’ve had a total of 5 chiropractic visits and I’m not only biking but am back to my 45 minute walks. I feel so good that I might start running again, but I don’t think I should push it so soon. At my age I’ve got to take things slow.

Is it a Meniscus Tear?

Well, as I said earlier, I won’t know unless I get an MRI. My knee isn’t popping anymore, the swelling is down and I’m back to doing everything I did before. I don’t see a need for an MRI. I’ll continue to keep an observant eye on my knee and keep getting regular chiropractic adjustments until my hips remain balanced. Thereafter I’ll go for the occasional chiropractic “tune up” as needed. If having my hips out of alignment was the true cause for this situation, I’d rather be proactive rather than reactive.

Is it a meniscus tear?  In my untrained, non-professional opinion, I don’t think so.

Tags: , , ,

Category: Aging, Alternative Care, Chiropractor, Far Infrared Lamp, Knees

About the Author ()

Felicia has learned the hard way that health, whether good or bad, is a result of daily choices and habits. On this blog Felicia shares what she's learned and the healthier choices she now makes as a result of her new knowledge. She hopes to encourage others to experiment to find alternative solutions to nagging problems (she's also is a bit of a tree hugger and likes to share ways to lighten the toxic burden on the environment). Necessary disclaimer: I am not a medical professional therefore I am not and cannot giving medical advice. I'm just sharing my story.

Comments (3)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. Loretta says:

    Hello Felicia, I had surgery 8 years ago for a torn meniscus in my right knee, so the title of your post grabbed my attention like a $50 bill lying in the grass (I found one years ago. Lucky day!)
    My knee adventure back in ‘09 didn’t begin with popping. Swelling, stiffness and pain was my wake up call. Like you, I was an avid walker (my favorite form of exercise at the time) and surgery was the last word I wanted to hear. Anyway, it all went well and I was soon back up to speed.
    A few months ago, the same knee began acting up again following what I self-diagnosed as hip bursitis, because the hip pain came first. Now, after reading your post, I am wondering if the problem is more of a hip alignment issue since I have developed an occasional limp on the same side. As I recall, the limp began a few months ago after I forced myself, on an very hot day, to walk extra laps around the park. And then, while walking home from the park, not only did I develop extreme pain in my right hip, I realized I was limping like a broke-leg praying mantis.
    Your article awakened me to the possibility that my now recurring pain, at joint points, in that leg may be the result of hip misalignment. My primary care doc has me scheduled to see a physiatrist (That’s physiatrist, not psychiatrist. LOL) next week so we’ll see what’s what.
    You’ve peaked my interest in trying various oils (Those oils are expensive!) because as far as I am concerned one surgery was enough and hoping around on crutches for about 4-5 weeks as I did following the first surgery is not my idea of exercising.Thanks for keeping us informed.

    • Felicia says:

      Hi Loretta,
      Sorry to hear about your meniscus surgery. I remember what my husband went through and that’s no joke! I had those visions in my mind when my chiro talked about meniscus surgery, although he said my situation would probably be fixed arthroscopically. Either way, I don’t want anyone going into my knee.

      Yes, some of the essential oils are expensive, but you only use a drop or two at a time. They have so many benefits.

      Regarding your limp, my first line of defense would be going to a chiropractor. Also, as we age, we’ve got to learn to listen to our bodies when they talk to us. That limp was telling you something, but like me, you ignored it in favor of meeting your exercise quota. I’m now learning to listen to the limp, ache or pain (sort of). The other day I was feeling so good on the bike that I decided to take on a hill. My chiro advised me to stay away from hills for a few weeks, but hard-headed Felicia decided to take it on.

      The next day I felt a little pain the knee. It was enough to let me know I’ll not take on another hill for a few more weeks. I continue to bike, but not hills. I’ve doubled my distance, but no hills for the time being. It’s tough listening to my body (and chiro), but I believe it will benefit me in the long run.

      I hope the physiatrist resolves your problem. If not, find a good chiropractor.

      Let me know how your situation improves.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *